Separation Anxiety Treatment: How to Know Whether Your Dog Is Making Progress
Sagi Denenberg, DVM, MRCVS, Dip. ACVB, Dip. ECAWBM, RCVS Recognised Specialist in Veterinary Behavioural Medicine.
Treatment for canine separation anxiety typically involves arranging support during absences and practicing departures of gradually increasing duration. Observable changes may include reduced vocalization or altered vigilance, such as persistent monitoring of the exit. Progress assessment should not rely solely on the duration. Treatment for canine separation anxiety generally involves arranging support during periods when the owner is away and practicing departures of increasing duration. Expected changes include reduced vocalization and/or a change in vigilance (e.g., the dog constantly watching the door as it closes). Do not judge progress solely by how long the owner is away or by the amount of property damage. A proper assessment of progress requires systematic observation of the dog’s behaviour before departure, during the absence, and on return. Comprehensive evaluation requires systematic observation of the dog’s behaviour before departure, during the absence, and upon return.
Establish what you are comparing
Start with recordings of naturally occurring absences rather than deliberately inducing distress. Position the cameras to cover the dog’s main resting areas and the exit, and record audio if possible. Record the circumstances: who is leaving and who is staying, time of day, any medication given and any unusual events that may have occurred just before the absence. Consider any environmental factors that may have been present (e.g. recent noise, visitors), as these may affect the dog’s behaviour and need to be considered when comparing absences to determine what is actually going on.
Track specific, observable behaviours. Appropriate metrics include latency to settle, total rest, and the presence of pacing, panting, vocalization, and/or repeated monitoring of the exit. Note both the time and duration of these behaviours, as a brief orientation to the door differs greatly from prolonged monitoring of the exit. Video studies have shown that direct behavioural observation is a far more accurate assessment method than inference from property damage or third-party reports.
Look for comfort rather than silence
A reduction in vocalization may signal progress, but consider it alongside the dog’s overall behavioural presentation. The lack of barking doesn’t mean the dog is relaxed, as other signs of anxiety may be present (e.g. tremors, hypersalivation, pacing, sustained muscular tension). Similarly, recumbency is not necessarily the same as relaxation if the dog is constantly on alert and is prone to startle responses. The key is to look for signs of relaxation such as a relaxed posture, reduced vigilance and the ability to lie down and/or interact with the environment. Resolution of anxiety cannot be judged based on a single behavioural parameter.
Feeding behaviour may offer additional insight, but eating in the owner’s absence is not, by itself, a reliable indicator of comfort. Some dogs will eat very quickly and then go on to show signs of distress; others will not eat for reasons which have nothing to do with anxiety. Record the behaviour before, during, and after feeding rather than assume comfort based on an empty feeding device. You also have to be able to tell the difference between apparent rest and immobility, which is a sign of tension. Discuss any uncertain observations with the supervising professional. The point is to be looking at the overall behavioural pattern rather than just the odd positive.
Measure the quality of an absence
The length of absences is a useful metric, but longer absences indicate progress only if the dog stays comfortable throughout. Absences of increasing length which are associated with escalating distress do not represent improvement in any way over a shorter absence in a relaxed state. Modify your gradual exposure protocol based on the dog’s actual response rather than a set schedule. Research on systematic desensitization shows a reduction in separation-related behaviours, but no evidence of a fixed timescale for all individuals. Adjust your protocol to the dog’s current tolerance and to the particular circumstances of each departure.
Assess progress in terms of consistent improvement across several comparable absences. Indicators of progress may include reduced latency to settle, fewer times exit monitoring is required, or the ability to maintain comfort during a departure routine that previously would have been quite distressing (all of which should occur before any significant increase in the length of absence). This is particularly important in the early stages of treatment. A reduction in symptom severity should not be the reason to continue to expose the individual to overt distress. If anxiety is present during practice, then subsequent sessions should be adjusted, and any ongoing problems should be discussed with the treatment team.
Keep a diary you can actually maintain
An effective diary should include the planned absence, the actual length of the absence, the principal behaviours observed, and relevant contextual factors (with a representative video recording). For example, it might note that the dog was resting for most of a 4-minute absence but started pacing after a sudden noise from outside. That kind of detail is far more useful than a simple ‘better’ or ‘worse’. Of course, you’d want to work with your supervising vet/behaviour professional to establish the most relevant metrics. That way, you’re not recording things that will be of very limited use.
Assessment should be long-term, looking at behavioural trends rather than trying to judge from a single absence whether the treatment is working. A single instance of increased difficulty may be attributable to several factors, such as poor sleep, being unwell, exposure to an aversive stimulus, or a change in routine. You can’t always be sure of the cause. A comparative review of the video footage will tell you whether the difficulty is a one-off or a recurring issue. You shouldn’t test the dog’s maximum tolerance repeatedly; simply returning to manageable practice sessions will give you a much more reliable indication of progress.
Assess medication and management together
If the plan involves medication, the record should include the time the medication is given and any changes in appetite, activity, sleep, or responsiveness that are observed. It is important to distinguish between sedation and genuine comfort, as a dog who is profoundly sedated (i.e. excessively drowsy) is a different proposition to one who is simply relaxed and able to rest. Report your observations to the vet in charge and do not alter the medication at all. Assess medication effectiveness alongside behavioural modification and absence management, as improvement may be due to several factors.
Practical management strategies will directly affect what can be achieved through behavioural intervention. If unavoidable absences consistently exceed the dog’s current capacity to cope, communicate this to the treatment team so the plan can be adjusted appropriately. Familiar people, alternative care options, or schedule changes may be used to reduce distress during treatment. These are all part of the care plan and do not represent a failure of the training. A good plan will take the dog’s welfare into account but will also be realistic in terms of the time available, the financial resources, and the level of support on offer.
Know when to review the plan.
A formal review is warranted if there is recurrent distress, the dog is not making any progress, new behaviours are appearing, or the medication is having an adverse effect. You will need to provide representative video clips and diary entries (both good and bad absences). The review may lead to changes in practice, a re-evaluation of the level of confinement, assessment of any possible medical factors and/or a change in the medication. Recovery times are very individual and cannot be pinned down. The best indicator of progress is a consistent trend of increasing comfortable, manageable absences as evidenced by regular behavioural observations.
References
Butler R, Sargisson RJ, Elliffe D. The efficacy of systematic desensitization for treating the separation-related problem behaviour of domestic dogs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 2011;129(2–4):136–145. DOI: 10.1016/j.applanim.2010.11.001.
Cannas S, Frank D, Minero M, Aspesi A, Benedetti R, Palestrini C. Video analysis of dogs suffering from anxiety when left home alone and treated with clomipramine. Journal of Veterinary Behavior. 2014;9(2):50–57. DOI: 10.1016/j.jveb.2013.12.002.








Comments